Employee Performance Issues

At Illinois, we prioritize direct and transparent conversations to address performance concerns. Our approach focuses on identifying issues, clarifying expectations, and ensuring accountability to uphold organizational standards. We aim to create an environment where employees understand what is expected of them and have access to the support they need to be successful. Please note that colleges, departments, and administrative units may also have specific bylaws that outline their processes for addressing performance concerns.

Our Process

Supervisors are encouraged to discuss performance concerns promptly. Timely discussions often lead to effective resolutions, as clear communication about issues and expectations are key.

If performance issues persist after initial conversations, supervisors should consider taking appropriate corrective steps as outlined below. Supervisors are encouraged to work with their departmental HR representatives on the best approach.

Labor and Employee Relations (LER) can provide guidance on performance management covering topics such as:

  • Management of attendance, productivity, and conduct concerns
  • Employee Policy Compliance
  • Corrective Action/Discipline

Employee Disciplinary Procedure


Civil Service Employees

The Performance Partnership Program (PPP) is a proactive performance management system for most civil service employees (Police Officers represented by FOP Local 126 are not included in PPP but a separate process detailed in their CBA). The PPP emphasizes recognizing and encouraging good performance while addressing any issues. Key principles of the PPP include:

  • Mutual Respect
  • Effective Communication
  • Constructive Feedback
  • Employee Responsibility
  • Commitment to High Work Standards
  • Positive Reinforcement

PPP fosters a supportive environment where coaching and counseling help employees make meaningful improvement and sustain those changes.

Positive Steps:

  • Positive Contact
  • Positive Recognition

Corrective Actions

Informal

  • Constructive Contact
  • Performance Improvement Discussion (PID)

Formal

  • Work Performance Reminder (WPR)—Active for 6 months*
  • Written Reminder (WR)—Active for 1 year*
  • Decision Making Leave (DML)—Active for 2 years*

*Provided there is no other formal corrective action during this time period.

Academic Professionals (AP) Employees

Letter of Expectations

A Letter of Expectations (LOE) is a formal written document used to outline specific concerns regarding an employee’s performance, behavior, conduct, and/or attendance. It serves as a key component of the performance management process, providing clarity around expectations and offering an opportunity for improvement.

An LOE typically includes:

  • A clear indication that the document is a formal Letter of Expectation
  • A summary of the identified issue(s)
  • Relevant dates of prior discussions
  • Clear expectations moving forward
  • A reasonable timeline for follow-up and improvement

Follow-up timelines should allow sufficient time for the employee to address and correct the concerns outlined.

If performance does not improve to an acceptable level following corrective steps, the employee may be subject to a Notice of Non-Reappointment. While it is generally expected that at least two LOEs will be issued prior to a Notice of Non-Reappointment, the number may vary depending on the circumstances.

Important Notes for Supervisors:

  • Supervisors must consult with their unit’s Human Resources representative before issuing an LOE.
  • LOEs may be reviewed by Labor and Employee Relations (LER), although such review is not mandatory.
  • LOEs should include a discussion between the supervisor and employee to clarify expectations and answer questions. HR may but is not required to be present for this discussion.

This guidance is intended to support consistent and fair application of the LOE process. Failure to follow these procedures does not automatically invalidate the corrective action taken.

For additional information or assistance with the LOE process, please contact Labor and Employee Relations at ihr-ler@illinois.edu or 217-333-3105.

Graduate Assistants

The employee disciplinary process for graduate assistants is outlined in the collective bargaining agreement for the Graduate Employee’s Organization.

Employees or supervisors needing more information about the disciplinary process for graduate assistants should contact Labor and Employee Relations at ihr-ler@illinois.edu or 217-333-3105.

Visiting APs

Visiting Academic Professionals (APs)

The employee disciplinary process for visiting academic professionals is outlined in the collective bargaining agreement for the Visiting Academic Professionals.

Employees or supervisors needing more information about the disciplinary process for Visiting APs should contact Labor and Employee Relations at ihr-ler@illinois.edu or 217-333-3105.

Collective Bargaining

Some employees are covered by a collective bargaining agreement (CBA). CBAs may contain specific provisions regarding performance management and performance reviews that must be adhered to. 

Is the employee represented by a union?  Each CBA contains a list of covered classifications. You can also search the represented union on the Civil Service Salary Plan for an employee’s classification. 

Illinois Human Resources
60 E. Marshall Street – MC 562,
Champaign, IL 61820
2173332137